Unhealthiest Careers

The jobs and industries with the highest health risks

Some jobs do more than help us earn money; they can also have a major impact on our health. Roles marked by high stress, paired with long hours or have higher risk of injury can leave lasting effects on health that can persist long after the workday ends. But which careers have the highest risks to our health?

To find out, health insurance comparison service iSelect analysed factors such as injury rates, distress scores, hours worked, commute times, job and financial security and health risk. Let’s take a closer look at the results.

Across the top ranked unhealthiest occupations, a clear pattern emerges of jobs that are physically demanding or operational roles with long or irregular hours paired with other poor lifestyle factors.

Protective Service Workers, such as Police Officers, Firefighters or Correctional Officers, were ranked at the top for the unhealthiest careers, scoring 68.26 out of 100. This is due to the demanding work patterns and environments, including night and shift work, high mental stress claims (9.48 per million hours of mental stress workers compensation claims over a five-year period), and elevated absenteeism (4.6% of workers affected by illness-related reduced hours per week, on average).

Other Labourers, including Freight Handlers and Shelf Fillers, placed second with a score of 57.97 out of 100, largely driven by the most severe health outcomes of any occupation. They recorded the highest physical injury rate (103.1 claims per million hours), reflecting the severity of bodily strain placed on workers in this career.

Rounding out the top three are Machine and Stationary Plant Operators (53.59). Although their health outcomes score was low (20.69), their ranking is driven by high risks in work patterns of shift work, their health behaviours and lifestyle. The demanding schedules, challenging environments, and physical and mental pressures clearly take a toll on workers’ health.

The data reveals that the Public Order, Safety and Regulatory Services was ranked as the unhealthiest industry; this includes Protective Service Workers. This is largely due to the sector’s high health outcomes, impact and harm score (74.63), with mental stress claims recorded at 9.29 per million hours and physical injury claims at 37.1 per million hours. High rates of psychological distress (13.9%) as well as a poor score in work patterns and environment (68.8), all contributing to its poor health profile for this industry.

Following behind is the Coal Mining industry, where extreme job design, high levels of night work (61.6%), and shift work (62.9%) intensify these risks and impact the overall score.

Residential Care Services, like Aged Care Workers or Support Workers, round out the top three (52.49). This is underpinned by mental stress claims (2.81 per million hours) and physical injury claims (32.3 per million hours). Nearly half of workers (42.1%) do shift work, and over a quarter (26.4%) regularly work at night, elevating the harm component.

Not all careers carry the same health risks. The data reveals that Farmers and Farm Managers have the healthiest career overall. This is influenced by the low health outcomes score (11.09), including the low mental stress claims (0.05 per million hours) and the lowest psychological distress rate (2%). There are also favourable behavioural indicators, such as high physical activity (49.7%).

Business, Human Resource and Marketing Professionals have the second healthiest career (23.21). They benefit from a low health outcomes risk and one of the lowest Work Pattern and Environment scores of 17.97. The high work from home rate (74.1%) also plays a key role in reducing stress and supporting overall well-being.

ICT professionals complete the top three heathiest careers with a score of 23.41. This occupation recorded the lowest Health Outcomes score across all careers (9.61), with minimal injury rates (0.4 claims per million hours) and low psychological distress (6.8%). With 82.6% able to work from home, these risks decline even further.

Overall, the healthiest occupations tend to be professional, office-based roles with low injury exposure and distress, as well as strong access to flexible working arrangements.

Interestingly, the healthiest industries often have low physical risks, a controlled and structured environment and limited exposure to acute incidents.

Auxiliary Finance and Insurance Services is the healthiest industry according to our data, scoring 20.86 out of 100. Both the health outcomes (12.26) and work pattern and environment (13.48) scores are extremely low, indicating minimal psychological and physical risk to workers. The industry clearly offers flexibility with just 2% working shifts, and more than three in four (79.3%) regularly working from home.

Similarly, Finance is the second healthiest industry, largely due to low levels of harm and exposure to physically demanding or hazardous work. The predictable, office-based environment means only 3% are doing shift work, and 72.4% are working from home.

Coming in third is the Telecommunication Services industry, scoring 22.48 out of 100. It has the lowest harm score across all industries (9.88), including low mental stress claims (0.11 per million hours), physical injury claims (1.8 per million hours), and rates of psychological distress (2.2%).

Unhealthiest

The Health Outcomes, Impact and Harm score shows the combined rate of mental stress claims, physical injury claims, psychological distress and absenteeism – all essential measures of workplace well-being and productivity.

The classification of ‘Other Labourers’, which includes Freight Handlers and Shelf Fillers, has the highest Health Outcomes score (65.87), driven by physical injury exposure (103.1 claims per million hours) and high psychological distress (17.8%).

Protective Service Workers follow (62.64), with elevated mental stress claims (9.48 per million hours) and physical injury rates (39.9 per million hours). Meanwhile, Health and Welfare Support workers rank third (58.12), experiencing high mental stress claims (4.92 per million hours), elevated psychological distress (16.6%), and the highest absenteeism rates among the top three (5.3%).

Interestingly, industries employing labourers, such as Fabricated Metal Product Manufacturing or Waste Collection, Treatment and Disposal Services, also rank among the unhealthiest for Health Outcomes, highlighting the strong link between physically demanding work and workplace harm.

Healthiest

ICT Professionals are the healthiest career in terms of Health Outcomes, scoring just 9.61 out of 100. This comes from minimal mental stress claims (0.08 per million hours) and the lowest physical injury rate (0.4 per million hours) of the study. Similarly, Farmers and Farm Managers rank second and also record low mental stress and psychological distress rates, likely due to the flexibility and outdoor work inherent to their roles.

Design, Engineering, Science, and Transport Professionals rank third because of modest injury exposure (3.4 per million hours) and extremely low absenteeism (2.8%).

Notably, the healthiest industries based on harm scores are dominated by white-collar and technical industries, led by Telecommunication Services with a score of 9.88, Motion Picture and Sound Recording Activities (12.07), and Auxiliary Finance and Insurance Services (12.26).

Unhealthiest

The Work Pattern and Environment score considers how job design and working conditions shape long-term health. A high score indicates that factors such as shift work, night work, commuting demands, and work flexibility are negatively impacting health.

Careers as Protective Service Workers have the highest Work Pattern and Environment score of 87.68, reflecting their extreme exposure to night work (67.9%), shift work (73.2%), and limited access to work from home (14.5%). Following closely are Machine and Stationary Plant Operators (78.13), who similarly face significant night work (45.8%), shift work (43.7%) and long commutes (37.5%). Given the hands-on nature of these roles, there is also minimal opportunity to work remotely.

Rounding out the top three are Road and Rail Drivers (55.77), though their score is more than 20 points lower than second-place. Workers in this role are responsible for operating vehicles to transport goods or people, which requires in-person presence, resulting in substantial night work (39.2%), shift work (26.6%), and very limited remote working options (5.8%).

In-person industries such as Coal Mining (93.56), Air and Space Transport (77.29), and Metal Ore Mining (75.65) rank among the unhealthiest in this category. Similarly, sectors like Public Order (68.80) and Rail Transport (68.43) also fall into this high-risk group.

Healthiest

In comparison, Numerical Clerks, responsible for compiling, recording, and processing financial data, record the lowest Work Pattern and Environment score (15.53). This is largely due to the minimal night work (10.1%), low shift work (2.2%) and more than half working from home (60.4%). Impressively, fewer than one in five commute more than 30 kilometres to work, contributing to lower fatigue and stress levels.

Once again, ICT Professionals rank as the second-healthiest, combining low shift work (1.6%) with the highest rate of working from home data across all careers (82.6%).

Coming in third are Office Administrators and Program Administrators. Built around a largely standard daytime schedule, this career is supported by low night work (13.9%) and greater opportunity to work from home (59.7%). Impressively, just 2.1% regularly engage in shift work, highlighting the consistency of work schedules that support employee wellbeing.

Just like the healthiest careers, the healthiest industries according to work-pattern are in the financial and professional services, led by Auxiliary Finance and Insurance Services (13.48), Insurance and Superannuation Funds (13.61), Computer System Design and Related Services (14.34), and Finance (14.58). These industries remain healthy because they pair low work-pattern risk with low harm outcomes.

Unhealthiest

Health Behaviours and Lifestyle Risk looks at everyday habits such as physical activity, smoking, alcohol use and diet, and particularly, how they affect long-term health. In the workplace, these behaviours are shaped less by the job and more by personal circumstances, social norms, and working environments.

According to the data, Mobile Plant Operators have the highest Health Behaviours and Lifestyle Risk score (87.94). The job’s limited physical activity (13.2%), high smoking rate (41.3%) and high alcohol risk (27.5%) contribute heavily to this result. Interestingly, despite ranking as the unhealthiest occupation for this category, almost half (42.1%) met fruit consumption guidelines.

Close behind are Construction Trades Workers, scoring 78.23 out of 100. The career has a high smoking rate (25.1%), an elevated alcohol risk (30.6%) and extremely low vegetable consumption (0.9% meeting guidelines). Time pressures, physical demands and worksite culture often reinforce these unhealthy habits.

Completing the top three are Automotive and Engineering Trade Workers, which also perform poorly with an unhealthiness score of 76.05. This score mainly comes from low physical activity (22.6%) and low vegetable consumption (0.6% meeting guidelines), while alcohol consumption was recorded by almost a third of workers (31.7%).

When looking at the unhealthiest industries in this category, they follow a similar pattern of being manual and operational industries. Wood Product Manufacturing, such as sawmilling and timber processing, topped the list with a score of 77.78. It was also featured in the top ten unhealthiest industries overall, scoring 46.54.

Healthiest

On the other end of the spectrum, Health Professionals, including Nurses and Allied Health, have the lowest lifestyle risk score (22.58). This is reflected in the lowest smoking rate (1.6%), minimal alcohol risk (5.4%) and a reasonably high vegetable consumption (10.3%). Ultimately, it is likely influenced by greater health awareness associated with working in the sector.

Education Professionals are the second healthiest (26.38), supported by very low smoking (0.6%) and low alcohol risk (5.4%). Similar to Health Professionals, those working in Education may benefit from higher health knowledge and a greater emphasis on wellbeing in their work environment.

Farmers and Farm Managers round out the top three (28.44), driven by very high physical activity (49.7%) despite moderate smoking (11.1%) and alcohol risk levels (13.4%).

Across industries, Publishing (excluding Internet and Music Publishing) (31.17) and Medical and Other Health Care Services (35.21) were the healthiest, driven by low smoking and alcohol use and high adherence to fruit intake guidelines. In both careers and industries, this pattern suggests that these sectors promote health awareness and well-being.

“The research shows that certain careers, like Protective Service Workers and Construction Trades Workers, carry higher health risks, with factors such as night shifts, physically demanding work, and limited opportunity to work from home contributing to fatigue, stress, and injury. This is concerning because prolonged exposure to these working conditions can have lasting effects on physical and mental well-being.

“To protect long-term health, there are practical steps workers can take, such as maintaining regular physical activity, limiting smoking and alcohol consumption, and eating a balanced diet rich in fruits and vegetables, which are all proven to support wellbeing. Employers can also play a role by providing flexible schedules, reducing unnecessary night or shift work, and creating safer, more supportive work environments. While some industries are leading the way, there is still a significant opportunity to improve health outcomes across many high-risk occupations.

“No matter your career, access to health insurance is critical, helping workers cover medical care, manage injuries and access preventative support. Having reliable health coverage provides peace of mind and allows workers to focus on maintaining good long-term health.”

Andres Gutierrez

General Manager – Health at iSelect

iSelect does not compare all health insurance providers or policies in the market. The availability of policies will change from time to time. Not all policies available from its providers are compared by iSelect and due to commercial arrangements, your stated needs and circumstances, not all policies compared by iSelect are available to all customers. Some policies and special offers are available only from iSelect’s contact centre or website. Click here to view iSelect’s range of providers